Extra Innings Paninos & Pizza
Home
Order Now
Menu
MVP Club
Fundraising
Store
Work With Us!
Extra Innings Paninos & Pizza
Home
Order Now
Menu
MVP Club
Fundraising
Store
Work With Us!
More
  • Home
  • Order Now
  • Menu
  • MVP Club
  • Fundraising
  • Store
  • Work With Us!
  • Sign In
  • Create Account

  • Orders
  • My Account
  • Signed in as:

  • filler@godaddy.com


  • Orders
  • My Account
  • Sign out

Signed in as:

filler@godaddy.com

  • Home
  • Order Now
  • Menu
  • MVP Club
  • Fundraising
  • Store
  • Work With Us!

Account


  • Orders
  • My Account
  • Sign out


  • Sign In
  • Orders
  • My Account

Play Ball!

Extra Innings has been crafting and delivering greatness for Marshall since 2002. We don't believe in fast food, we believe in GREAT FOOD!  Each of our delicious Paninos and Pizzas are crafted to order on our famous flatbread and baked to perfection. It may take a little extra time, but we believe it's worth it!

Download Our Menu or Scroll Through!

W2025 Online Menu (pdf)Download

Our Menu

Starters

Start your game off right with one of our delicious Appetizers!

Fried Cheese Curds with Ranch Dressing

Cheese Curds

11.99

White Cheddar Wisconsin Cheese Curds fried to perfection. Served with Pub Ranch.

A mound of fries topped with nacho cheese, bacon, onion and sour cream

Bases Loaded Fries

14.99

A mound of Fries, Oles or Tots loaded with Nacho Cheese, Bacon, Onion with a side of Sour Cream.

Fried Fritter Style Chicken Strips with Ranch Dressing

Chicken Strips

12.99

Choice of Ranch Dressing, Honey Mustard or BBQ Sauce.

Chips & Queso

7.99

Pub Ole Seasoned Tortilla Chips with a side of Queso.

Perfectly fried chislic bites with a side of tater tots.

House Cut Chislic

16.99

Fried Tender Marinated Beef Chislic served with your choice of side and A1 Sauce.

Detroit Cheese Bread with marinara.

Detroit Cheese Bread

11.99

Our Detroit Style Dough loaded with Mozzarella, Cheddar & Parmesan Cheese. Served with Marinara Sauce. Add Pepperoni or Italian Sausage for 2.00. Add Jalapenos for 1.00.

A platter with Spinach & Artichoke Dip, Buffalo Chicken Dip, tortilla chips and house-made crackers

Double Dipper

12.99

Fresh Baked Flatbread & Pub Ole Seasoned Tortilla Chips served with Buffalo Chicken & Spinach Artichoke Dips.

Fried Ravioli with marinara and ricotta cheese.

Fried Ravioli

10.99

Four Cheese Ravioli with Marinara and Seasoned Ricotta.

a mound of nachos loaded with toppings

Tiger Nachos

14.99

Pub Ole Seasoned Tortilla Chips loaded with Creamy Queso, Seasoned Beef or Chicken, Lettuce, Black Olive, House Pickled Jalapeno, Onion & Tomato served with Salsa & Sour Cream.

Traditional Buffalo Dry Rub Wings with Celery and Ranch Dressing.

Wings

Extra Innings offers Wings for every sports fan. | One sauce per order. Each order comes with our own Bleu Cheese or Ranch Dressing and Celery Sticks. | 8 Traditional Single Order- 14.99, Double Order-28.99, Triple Order 42.99 or over 1/2 pound of Boneless Wings. Single Order- 12.99, Double Order-24.99, Triple Order 36.99.


Paninos

Let’s be honest, it’s why you’re here! A craft flatbread sandwich made on our Famous Homemade Dough. Served with your choice of Coleslaw, Kettle Chips or Tortilla Chips. Upgrade to French Fries, Sweet Potato Fries, or Tater Tots for +$2. $2.99 to split in two, this includes an additional Base Side and Pickle

Burger Battle Chopped Cheese

Redwood River Farms Grass-Fed Ground Beef, Onions, Bell Peppers, 3-Cheese Blend, Nacho Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and our Burger Sauce.

H 11.95

F 16.95

A Panino filled with fettuccine noodles, chicken and cheese with a side of Alfredo sauce and fries.

Alfredo Pie

Fettuccine Noodles and Mozzarella Cheese with Alfredo Sauce with your choice of Chicken, Popcorn Shrimp, Crab or Veggie.

No Meat: H 8.29 F 13.29

Chicken: H 9.29 F 14.49

Crab: H 9.29 F 14.49

Popcorn Shrimp: H 10.29 F 17.99

Crab & Popcorn Shrimp: H 12.49 F 19.99

Southwest

A Mustang Favorite! Chicken or Steak, Bacon, Onions, Bell Peppers and Lettuce with Extra Innings’ own Mustang Sauce.

Chicken: H 9.99 F 16.49

Steak: H 11.29 F 19.79

Pulled Pork: H 11.29 F 19.79

A delicious Hall Of Fame Burger Panino with Tater Tots.

NEW! Hall Of Fame Burger

Redwood River Farms Grass-fed Beef, Candied Bacon, Three Cheese Blend, Pickled Red Onion, Arugula and Balsamic Glaze. H- 11.79 F- 19.49

A delicious Buffalo Chicken Panino with a pickle spear and sweet potato fries.

Buffalo Chicken

Once you try it you’ll be hooked! Tender Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, and Celery. Your choice of any of our 20+ Wing Sauces with either Ranch or Bleu Cheese. H 8.49 F 13.99

Add Steroids! (Ham & Bacon) +3

A delicious Club panino

The Club

Loaded with Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Cheddar, Broccoli Florets, Crisp Lettuce, Tomatoes and Mayo. H 10.49 F 17.49

Cluckin' Good Chicken Sandwich with crispy chicken, mozzarella cheese, spicy mayo, pickles &lettuce

NEW! Cluckin' Good Chicken

Crispy Chicken, Mozzarella, Spicy Mayo, Pickle & Lettuce. H- 9.29 F- 14.99

Buffalo Mac-Nino Panino with pickle and chips

Buff Mac-Nino

Macaroni Noodles, Cheddar & Mozzarella Cheese, Creamy Queso, Crispy Chicken and Buffalo Sauce.

H 9.99 F 16.49

Sandwich with crispy chicken, ham, cheddar, onion, pickle, spicy maple BBQ & coleslaw.

NEW! Canadian BBQ

Crispy Chicken, Ham, Cheddar, Onion, Pickle, Spicy Maple BBQ & Coleslaw. H- 9.99 F- 16.99

Three Meat BBQ

Loaded with Chicken, Ham, Bacon, Mozzarella Cheese Dripping in BBQ Sauce.

H 9.99 F 16.99

Classic Sicilian

Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Onion, Bell Pepper, Mushroom, Mozzarella, Arugula, Tomato & Creamy Italian Dressing. H 10.49 F 17.99

a delicious Chicken Bacon Ranch Panino

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Your choice of Crispy or Grilled Chicken with Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato and Pub Ranch. H 9.99 F 15.49

A delicious Philly steak panino

Philly

Chicken or Steak, Fresh Mushrooms, Onions, Bells Peppers, Mozzarella Cheese and Queso Blanco. 

Chicken: H 9.29 F 15.49

Steak: H 11.99 F 19.99

A delicious Cuban Panino with a pickle spear and chips.

Cuban

House Smoked Redwood River Farms’ Pulled Pork & Ham, Mozzarella Cheese, Pickles and Yellow Mustard. H 10.99 F 17.99

Panino with around beed, cheddar, rice, black beans & queso.

NEW! Burrito Panino

Seasoned Chicken or Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Black Beans, Cilantro Lime Rice, Creamy Queso, Sour Cream & Salsa. H 10.49 F 17.99


Pizza

When we say “Homemade” we mean it! Our Pizzas are made from the same famous dough that we use to make our paninos! Choose our Prairie Style Crust(Thin), Camden(Thick) +$1, or Detroit Style(Pan with Crispy Cheese Frico) +$1, House Made Gluten Free Focaccia(While made entierly of Gluten Free ingredients we cannot guarantee this to bee 100% Gluten Free. It is made in a kitchen with high levels of gluten present and crops-contamination may occur.) +$2

A delicious pizza loaded with Build Your Own toppings.

BYO Pizza

Cheese Options: Bacio Premium Mozzarella, Cheddar, House Blend(Mozzarella, Cheddar, Meunster), Parmesan. Protein Options: Chicken, Ham, Ground Beef, Taco Beef, Italian Sausage, Pulled Pork, Steak, Pepperoni, Turkey, Bacon, Crispy Chicken, Crab, Popcorn Shrimp, Cup n Char Pepperoni. Sauce Options: Pizza Sauce, Alfredo Sauce, Garlic Butter Sauce, Cheeseburger Sauce. Single topping with cheese 9.49. Additional toppings extra.

A delicious Backstop Pizza Loaded with toppings

The Backstop

17.99

Cup n Char Pepperoni, House Made Italian Sausage, Mushrooms, Onions, Bell Peppers, Green Olives, Black Olives & Bacio Mozzarella. 

A super cheesy macaroni and cheese pizza

Mac n Cheese

10.45

Alfredo Sauce, Macaroni Noodles, Mozzarella & Cheddar Cheese. Add Brisket, Jalapeños & BBQ Sauce for 4.95!

pizza with Alfredo Sauce, Chicken, Bacon, Onion, cheese and drizzle of bbq & ranch

NEW! I'm Not a Player, I Just Cluck A Lot

12.99

Alfredo Sauce, Tender Chicken, Bacon, Onion, House Cheese Blend, BBQ Sauce & Ranch. 

pizza with garlic dill sauce, dill pickles and mozzarella.

NEW! Dilly Of A Pickle

11.49

Garlic Dill Seasoned Alfredo Sauce, Dill Pickles & Mozzarella.

A delicious grand slam all-meat pizza

Grand Slam

15.99

Loaded with our House Recipe Deutz Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Ground Beef, Ham & Bacon topped with Bacio Mozzarella Cheese

Freshly baked Pennant Pepperoni Pizza with beautiful cup n char pepperoni on top.

Pennant Pepperoni

10.49

Loaded with Classic and Cup N Char Pepperoni with Bacio Mozzarella.

Add Jalapeno & Mike’s Hot Honey $1.99

pizza with red sauce, cheese blend, sausage, beef, ham and ricotta cheese dollops.

NEW! The Redwood

17.99

Redwood River Farms' Ground Beef, Ham & Italian Sausage, House Cheese Blend, Seasoned Ricotta & Spicy Maple Syrup.

White Chicken & Bacon

12.99

Alfredo Sauce, Chicken, Bacon, & Mozzarella Cheese


Pubzones

Calzones crafted to order on our famous homemade dough and baked to perfection! Choose from one of our house recipes or create your own!

Classico

9.49

Pepperoni, Italian Sausage, Mozzarella, Marinara, Parmesan and Oregano.

Smoke Show

9.49

House-smoked Pulled Pork, Three Cheese Blend, Pickled Red Onion & BBQ Sauce.

Caprese

9.49

Tender Chicken, Premium Mozzarella, Basil, Roma Tomato, Alfredo & Balsamic Glaze.


The Dugout

A fresh lineup of hearty salads, flavorful rice bowls, and satisfying pasta, perfect for those seeking something beyond the usual game-day fare. Whether you're in the mood for something light or loaded with flavor, you'll find a winning option here!

A fresh salad of arugula, bright carrots and red cabbage with cashews and dressing.

Cashew Chicken Salad

15.99

Arugula, Tender Chicken, Cashews, Bell Pepper, Onion, Carrot, Cabbage with Asian Sesame Dressing.

A taco salad with tortilla chips, cheddar cheese, black olives, tomato, salsa and sour cream

Taco Salad

13.99

Shredded Lettuce, Seasoned Ground Beef or Chicken, Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives, Tomatoes & Tortilla Chips. Served with Sour Cream and Salsa.

A delicious Caesar Salad with tomatoes,  croutons and parmesan cheese.

Chicken Caesar

13.99

Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Homemade Garlic Flavored Croutons, Tomatoes & Parmesan Cheese.

Burrito Bowl

10.49

Choice of Cilantro Lime Rice or Quinoa & Kale Blend, Creamy Queso, Black Beans, Lettuce, Tomato, Pub Oles, Sour Cream & Salsa. 

Add Chicken +$4 Beef +$6

Asian Bowl

9.99

Choice of Cilantro Lime Rice or Quinoa & Kale Blend, Onion, Bell Pepper, Pineapple, choice of Asian Sesame, Sweet Chili or Teriyaki Sauce and Sesame Seeds.

Add Chicken +$4 Steak +$6

Buffalo Bowl

12.99

Choice of Cilantro Lime Rice or Quinoa & Kale Blend, Creamy Queso, Bleu Cheese Crumbles, Crispy Chicken, Celery, Choice of Wing Sauce, Ranch Dressing

BBQ Pork Mac n Cheese

16.99

Creamy Macaroni & Cheese topped with House-smoked Pulled Pork, Pickled Red Onion, Pickled Red Onion and BBQ Sauce.

a bowl of fettuccine Alfredo with a fresh baked breadstick

Baked Alfredo

11.99

Fettuccine Noodles, Creamy Alfredo Sauce, Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese. 

Add Chicken +$4

a plate with a huge serving of lasagna dusted with parmesan and parsley

Baked Lasagna

15.99

Layered Lasagna Noodles, Marinara, Italian Sausage and Seasoned Ricotta topped with House Cheese Blend and Parmesan Cheese.

Copyright © 2025 Extra Innings Paninos & Pizza - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by

  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions

Join our NEW MVP Club!

We're starting a new MVP Club & we want you to be a part of it! For all of the latest updates and best deals sign up today!

Join Now!

This website uses cookies.

We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

Accept